This post may earn affiliate income from links and/or review products to help support this site from the companies .
A Beautiful Noise at the Keller Auditorium — A Powerful, Joyful, Deeply Nostalgic Broadway Experience
JANUARY 6 – 11, 2026
Tickets are available online at www.BroadwayinPortland.com
Some Broadway shows impress you with spectacle. Some wow you with vocals. And then—every once in a while—you experience a show that delivers all of that AND feels personal, like it’s gently tapping into memories you didn’t even realize were still living inside you.
That’s exactly what A Beautiful Noise does.
Now playing at the Keller Auditorium through January 11th, this production is far more than a jukebox musical. It’s a beautifully told life story—honest, emotional, and delivered in a unique format that flows effortlessly from beginning to end. Simply put: it’s amazing.
A Storytelling Format That Instantly Pulls You In
What stood out to me immediately was the structure of the show. Instead of a predictable, chronological timeline, the story unfolds through Neil Diamond reflecting on his life—literally conversing with his younger self. This approach works so well. It allows the audience to experience not just the successes, but the internal struggles: the insecurity, ambition, ego, vulnerability, and emotional cost of becoming a legend.
It never feels confusing or disjointed. The story moves smoothly, intentionally, and emotionally, keeping you fully engaged from start to finish.
Nick Fradiani Is Absolute Perfection as Neil Diamond
Let’s talk about Nick Fradiani, because his performance deserves its own spotlight. From the moment he stepped on stage, it was clear: this wasn’t an imitation. This was an embodiment.
His voice, sound, physicality, and mannerisms are spot on. Vocally, he’s powerful, controlled, and emotionally grounded. He doesn’t just sing Neil Diamond’s songs—he inhabits them. There were moments where I genuinely forgot I was watching an actor perform. His confidence mixed with vulnerability made the performance feel authentic, respectful, and deeply compelling.
Old Neil vs. Young Neil — A Brilliant Contrast
The decision to show Neil Diamond at two stages of his life is one of the show’s smartest choices. Robert Westenberg, portraying the older, reflective Neil, brings depth, warmth, and understated humor to the role. He isn’t flashy—and that’s exactly why it works.
Watching young Neil and old Neil interact adds emotional layers you simply wouldn’t get with a traditional narrative. It humanizes him. It grounds the story. And it invites the audience to reflect right along with him.
Nostalgia That Hits You Right in the Heart
If you’ve grown up with Neil Diamond’s music in any capacity—and honestly, most of us have—this show will hit you emotionally. These songs aren’t just hits. They’re memories. Family gatherings. Long drives. Lyrics you didn’t realize you still knew by heart.
Every song is placed intentionally, enhancing the story rather than interrupting it. The nostalgia feels earned, not forced—and that makes all the difference.
Marcia Murphey: A Love Story You Learn to Embrace
One of the most compelling parts of the show is its portrayal of Neil Diamond’s relationship with Marcia Murphey. Played by Mary Page Nance, Marcia is magnetic—sexy, confident, seductive, and emotionally layered.
Yes, the relationship began as an affair. But rather than simplifying or judging it, the show allows you to understand it. This was not a passing moment—it was a 25-year relationship, and it mattered deeply. By the end of the show, you don’t just accept Marcia—you truly love her. Mary Page Nance brings so much warmth and dimension to the role that she becomes an emotional anchor of the entire production.
Simple, Smart, and Effective Production Design
The set design is refreshingly simple and intentional, allowing the story and music to remain front and center. Clean visuals, thoughtful staging, and seamless transitions keep the show moving at a perfect pace.
And the backup dancers? So fun. They add energy, movement, and personality to each era of Neil Diamond’s career without ever overwhelming the story. Their choreography enhances the music and brings each chapter of his life to vivid, joyful life.
A Must-See Broadway Experience in Portland
A Beautiful Noise is heartfelt, nostalgic, joyful, and beautifully crafted. It honors Neil Diamond’s legacy while showing the man behind the music—flaws, brilliance, vulnerability, and all. Whether you’re a lifelong Neil Diamond fan or simply someone who loves powerful storytelling and standout performances, this show delivers on every level.
Now playing at the Keller Auditorium through January 11th—don’t miss it.
Leave a Reply